The fault line: How to communicate in a crisis

“In the midst of chaos, there is also opportunity”

Sun Tzu, The Art of War

If there’s one universal constant in the world of business, it’s that things will go wrong. Probably at the most inconvenient of times and in the most inconvenient of ways. It’s Murphy’s law, or, if you’re from England the much more fun, “Sod’s law”. These moments can define your business more than any other. Unfortunately, far more than usual day-to-day ever will. After all, you’ll never have more eyes on your business than when you’re in a crisis (especially if you have something like unscheduled website downtime). 

The decisions you make when things go wrong can actually create strong brand loyalty and customer trust – if you do it right. Here are my tips on managing your way through a crisis and coming out stronger:

1. Own the problem, no matter who is at fault

The first step to managing a crisis is to understand what the crisis is, where it starts and ends, and how much of it is in your control. That doesn’t mean working out every last detail, but it’s good to come out ahead.

Pre-emptive measures like website monitoring can help mitigate problems and make you aware of issues before the first report comes in. Nothing shows a company is on the ball like going to report a problem only to see the company is already working on the solution.

It’s also important to get into the mindset that no matter where the problem really lies, as far as your customers are concerned, it lies with you.  

No, you can’t prepare for everything, but the good news is the majority of customers don’t expect you to. When we talk about ownership, what we’re really looking for is accountability. And that means taking responsibility for all problems. Not just ones caused by something you’ve done, but all external factors. 

Let’s say, for example, AWS goes down. 

Was it your fault? No, but it is your problem. Customers want the problem fixed, but they may also want to vent, and they want to know someone is listening and emphasises with them. It’s human nature to want to complain, but it’s also human nature to be defused by a sympathetic voice.

2. Don’t get information paralysis

One of the biggest mistakes companies make during a crisis is “information paralysis” where they get into a cycle of holding off on communicating until they get every last piece of information on a problem. 

Or, worse, they won’t post until after they’ve solved the problem in some big flashy solution. This works for Tony Stark, but chances are, it isn’t going to work for you. Sorry to ruin your Iron Man fantasies!

Perhaps companies feel that updating people with information that may itself change is confusing. Or perhaps that coming to the table with a problem and no solution looks ill-prepared. In reality, though, nothing makes you look less prepared than burying your head in the sand. This sort of logic is nearly always doing your customers a disservice, anyway.

We live in a world of 24 hour live online news where information is drip-fed constantly, and often reports and Tweets and stories are updated and changed around us. In that environment, it’s a little naive to think your customers won’t be able to handle a little live update about your product.

Ultimately, establishing a dialogue is more important than getting everything perfect straight away. If you make a mistake or need to change something, it’s not the end of the world. It makes you seem more human, and that builds empathy. 

3. Pick the right channels for the right messaging

Where and how you talk to your customers during ‘peacetime’ may not be the same as where you talk to them during a crisis. No matter what’s gone wrong, it’s important to remember the method of communication can be just as important as the words themselves.

One common mistake people make is leaving the crisis talk solely to Twitter or Facebook. Social media, which is ephemeral by its very nature, is an easy fall-back for quick updating. However, its limited word-count can make apologies and communication seem terse and insincere. Nobody wants to see an apology with a hashtag in it.

One middle-ground comms method that you may not have considered is a status service, like StatusCake Pages. You may already be sharing public data about your website’s performance and uptime, but tools like StatusCake Pages allow you to communicate issues outside of your control.

Status Page alerts can provide a great middle-ground because they’re more visible and quicker to write than a blog, but they’re more sincere and flexible than a Tweet. You can write what you need to write without worrying about character limits, and by doing so you will come across as more genuine and involved in the situation.

Allowing your customers to subscribe to these status updates also presents an image of transparency. Rather than your company looking like it’s attempting to hide failures out of sight, it becomes one that acknowledges, reacts and solves issues. 

Plus, you can avoid information paralysis because unlike more hefty methods of communications like a newsletter, there’s no pressure to get everything perfect in a single post. The more status posts you create, the more actively it looks like your team is trying to solve the problem.

While we’re on the subject of messaging, don’t forget to turn off all scheduled marketing communication that may have been planned during the crisis.

Not only is it a waste of money and effort on your part but there is nothing worse for a customer than a flashy push notification about your “biggest discounts ever” while they’re getting an error 500 on your login page!

4. Always follow-through

Honesty and ownership are what we’re aiming for here, so avoid making promises that you can’t keep. Sometimes the hardest part of a crisis is when the answer to a user’s question is very simply “I don’t know.” It’s easy to want to follow that up with timelines or solutions, but sometimes communication is about knowing when not to speak.

Your customers are only human, and we humans are a simple species. We’re far more annoyed by a promise that isn’t kept than by some random software outage. You’re more likely to lose a customer by lying to them than you are ignoring them (but it’s best to avoid doing both!)

Following-through isn’t just about making promises though, it’s about ending your crisis with care. When the main problem has been resolved, it’s very easy to want to sweep it all under the rug and try to move on as quickly as possible, but that can be dangerous. 

Customers and even staff appreciate closure around these issues. This can be as simple as reaching out individually to customers affected to check if the problem has been solved, even if you know it has. 

Dedicated changelog services like ChangeCrab are also a great place to talk about the particular problems that you faced in greater detail, and with the benefit of hindsight.

Changelogs can be a more effective method of communication for this sort of post-mortem because they tend to be where your most engaged customers will come to learn about the more in-depth parts of your business, while also being a place new users will stop by to see how you handled past problems and how often you update.

No matter how bad the problem is, all things pass and the world will move on. What will be left online is the record of how you dealt with the crisis, which will help new customers understand how you’ll handle them in the future. 

I hope this helps! While you may not be looking forward to your next big problem, take comfort that if you communicate well, some good can always come out of even the most trying situations!

Share this

More from StatusCake

Google algorithm
How To

The ultimate Google Algorithm update checklist for your website

4 min read It’s time – Google’s algorithm update is set to come into play this month and that means that thousands of websites are going to be impacted. Is yours ready for the update? Use our algorithm checklist to make sure you’ve ticket everything off before it affects your SEO rankings.


10 of the best podcasts you should be listening to right now

6 min read Struggling to find a podcast that you want to listen to? Or never tried to listen to a podcast on your daily walk? Here’s our top 10 podcasts that you definitely should be listening to whether you like entertainment news, sports, tech or business podcasts.

computer interacting with people across the globe
How To

How to promote affiliate links and monetize your blog

6 min read Affiliate marketing is on the rise and it’s not surprising considering how much money can be made for such little effort. Whether you’re simply looking to just add an affiliate link to your website or blog, or you want more inventive ways to make a commission with affiliate marketing then read our helpful guide to get you started.

project Bernanke lawsuit
In The News

Project Bernanke – Google’s Secret Ace

3 min read You may have heard whispers of Google’s lawsuit regarding Project Bernanke but we’ve got the downlow on everything you need to know about exactly what Project Bernanke is and why the State of Texas is filing a lawsuit against them.

How To

The 5 easiest ways to spot a fake website in seconds

5 min read Do you know how to spot a fake website? No? Stop what you’re doing. Literally stop. You need to read these quick 5 ways of noticing instantly if the website you’re on is trustworthy or not. Hold onto those credit card details until you do!


8 major websites that you won’t believe went down in April

4 min read You might be surprised to learn that even mega famous, widely-used companies like Amazon and eBay experience website downtime. They’re not the only ones. Find out the big 8 that have gone down this April and how you can monitor your uptime!

Join our newsletter & we'll donate $0.50* to the 999 Club charity

Get weekly inspiration & hacks from our expert blogs plus exclusive access to podcasts and discounts.

*Up to $250 per month